Reinsurance Specialties

Direct Procurement: The Supreme Court Precedent Beneath The Latitude Plan

From 100 bales of Louisiana cotton in 1897 to Todd Shipyards in 1962: the Supreme Court cases establishing that insurance is regulated where it's procured, not where the insured sits. This is the case law beneath The Latitude Plan.

Reinsurance Specialties Team

Every sophisticated structure should be able to answer one question plainly: what gives you the right? For The Latitude Plan, the answer is a doctrine with a four-case Supreme Court pedigree dating to 1897: direct procurement. The principle is that insurance is regulated and taxed where the transaction is procured, not where the insured property happens to sit.

1897: Allgeyer v. Louisiana

The origin case is charmingly small: 100 bales of cotton worth $3,400, sitting in Louisiana, insured by mail through a New York insurer with no Louisiana agent or office. Louisiana fined the owner for dealing with an unlicensed insurer. The Supreme Court struck the fine. The contract was made in New York, and Louisiana couldn't reach a transaction that occurred outside its borders, even though the insured property was inside them.

1922 and 1938: the principle hardens

St. Louis Cotton Compress Co. v. Arkansas (1922) closed the relabeling loophole: calling the penalty a "tax" changed nothing. Where no part of the transaction occurs in-state, the state has no authority. Connecticut General Life Insurance Co. v. Johnson (1938) extended the doctrine to reinsurance itself: California could not tax reinsurance premiums on California risks where the reinsurance agreements were made and performed in Connecticut.

1945 and 1962: Congress writes it into statute, the Court confirms

After United States v. South-Eastern Underwriters (1944) held that insurance is interstate commerce, Congress passed the McCarran-Ferguson Act of 1945, deliberately returning insurance regulation to the states. As the House Report put it, states have no power "to tax contracts of insurance or reinsurance entered into outside its jurisdiction." In State Board of Insurance v. Todd Shipyards Corp. (1962), Texas tested that line with a premium tax on directly procured coverage of undisputedly Texas property. The Court struck the tax and held that McCarran-Ferguson had effectively codified the Allgeyer doctrine into federal law. Texas courts applied the same rule as recently as Dow Chemical v. Rylander (2001).

Why this matters to your structure

Under The Latitude Plan, your operating company procures its policies directly, and the procurement activity is deliberately conducted so that it occurs in the reinsurance company's domestic sovereign domicile, not in your state. That is the arrangement the Allgeyer line has protected for more than a century, operating today in an economy where transactions routinely occur in no particular state at all. The structure is designed to sit squarely inside that case law.

Direct procurement is one leg of the framework. The tax-law leg is the four-part insurance test, the designation leg is 831(a) versus 831(b), and the domicile leg is covered in the sovereign domestic domicile (for a recent measure of that domicile's standing, see AGII's Lloyd's reinsurance agreement). The assembled framework, with all citations, lives on Structure & Oversight, and the structure & domicile FAQ handles the practical questions.

Book a Call

One hour. No obligation.

A one-hour presentation of The Latitude Plan, then your questions. Your CPA or attorney is welcome on the line.

More insights